"Fussball ist wie Schach, nur ohne WÜrfel".
- Football is like chess, just with no dice.
2012-10-20-15.11.56-680x510

Dynamo’s lesson in irony

Posted on: October 22nd, 2012 by Stephen, Image © 9 Comments

When I saw the flyer for Dynamo v Lichtenberg, I made a decision: I definitely wouldn’t be going to that game. I’d go to Babelsberg, who were playing at the same time, and had never (as far as I know) resorted to breathtakingly tasteless, ignorant, self-obsessed and narcissistic ‘jokes’ in an attempt to get more people to their games.

If you don’t know what I’m talking about, here’s a quick summary: Dynamo fans made a flyer for the Lichtenberg game with the phrase ‘Erich had to take this route too.’ It was a reference to the Lichtenberg 47 home ground being right beside the Stasi headquarters in Normannenstraße, and the route that Stasi boss Erich Mielke would have taken on his way to watch Dynamo. While the club made it clear that fans acting alone were responsible, the response from the Dynamo authorities did not exactly distance themselves from the idea: “The media response was huge. Now lots of people know that we’re playing against Lichtenberg. That’s not usually the case. From this point of view, the action was successful,” said press officer Martin Richter. A bizarre statement, considering how anxious the Dynamo powers that be have been in recent years to remove preconceptions of the club.

So I had made my decision to definitely avoid the game, when, on Friday, I received a beautifully earnest email from a Berlin football fan, asking No Dice to consider coming watch his team. His team? BFC Dynamo. So, like he asked, I considered it. I thought about the Dynamo fans who would glorify the actions of a man so anxious to maintain the status quo of the dictatorship that gave him so much power that he would create a network of informers, one for every four citizens. But then I thought about the Dynamo fans that I have actually met in person, who eruditely reject these asinine portrayals of the club – intelligent, open-minded individuals who wished that Dynamo could be simply a football team.

And so I decided to go to Dynamo, and to go for the fact that, like many of their fans, I simply want them to be a football team supported by people who want to watch football. Despite stupid, attention- and outrage-seeking flyers. And, as it happened, it appeared as though most of the 1,012 present had turned up to watch football too (the few who raised a banner listing the years of the DDR Oberliga title wins aside, with the interesting ‘Zurück zu alter Stärke’ below it (‘back to the strength of old’). With a Mielke banner paraded around that same, sparsely populated section of terrace, one can’t help but think that that the Stärke can’t have referred to footballing dominance).

From the off, the referee Petrit Velici was unnecessarily pernickety, drawing the ire of the home fans for a series of soft free-kicks for and against both teams. Dynamo took advantage of the stop-start openings, Matthias Steinborn finishing excellently under Danny Kempter in the Lichtenberg goal with just seven minutes on the clock. From then on Dynamo looked in control without ever being threatening – Nico Patschinski was isolated on the left wing and was well tracked by Marinko Becke, who was roundly booed at every touch after having made the most of a crunching Christian Preiss tackle right in front of the main stand.

On a rare Lichtenberg attack, Kadir Erdil took a spill just inside the box, and the referee, despite howls of protest, pointed to the spot. It was a soft penalty, but Sebastian Reiniger didn’t care: he smashed it right down the middle, and Dynamo keeper Carsten Busch was lucky to have dived out of the way – it’d have taken his head otherwise. Reiniger’s subsequent Stuart Pearce-like celebration indicated that he was quite pleased at having scored against Dynamo.

After the break, the introduction of Ibrahim Keser to the Dynamo attack added a great deal of dynamism and pace to the previously static frontline, but at the price of organisation and stability: for every penetrating run, Keser also gave Lichtenberg an easy counterattack by losing the ball in risky positions. Frustrating for the home manager, but it certainly made for an enthralling second half. Lichtenberg’s substitute Moussa Doumbia was finding plenty of space in behind the Dynamo defence, and with his best opportunity, nearly broke the crossbar with a thundering effort from close range.

As the clock ticked down, the guests did everything in their power to ensure that the ball was out of play for most of the ticking. Cramps and mystery injuries were rife as Dynamo pushed forward, and, as an injury to Marinko Becke left a huge gaping hole in the centre of defence, Steinborn once more ran clear and tucked the ball under Kempter. The flag was up though, and, although the decision was borderline, the fact that Becke had been lying injured for a good twenty seconds as Dynamo played on meant that justice, perhaps, had been done with a 1-1 draw. The result leaves both teams six points adrift of NOFV Oberliga Nord leader Luckenwalde – for promoted Lichtenberg, a upper mid-table spot is more than satisfactory, but for promotion-hunting Dynamo, unbeaten since the opening day of the season, the inability to finish off the games that they dominate is what sets them aside from their higher-placed rivals.

And now, if I may, a brief conclusion on the flyer controversy before No Dice wipes the Dynamo slate clean once more. If you’re bored of it, feel free to stop reading here.

A variety of statements from fans on Facebook decried those offended by the flyer as not having the capacity to understand irony – itself an ironic statement, and here’s why. Satire requires those consuming the joke to fully understand the standpoint of those making the joke. We, i.e. the non Dynamo-supporting public, are not yet ready to hear these Dynamo in-jokes, because the club, with its Mielke banners and hooligans ready to hijack any big occasion, have not shown us that the club has moved on (and the yells of ‘Schieber, Schieber’ against today’s referee, to me, appeared glaringly free of irony). The bubble of in-jokes and martyrdom that BFC Dynamo exists in cannot last forever. Bursting it from within is the only way it can ever be anything other than what it was.

RSS Feed

9 Responses

  1. Bill Sheppard says:

    What a vile piece of work BFC are, the only club I find more morally reprehensible than MK Franchise. And if BFC are playing Oranienburg, I dread to what are going to be on those flyers…

  2. Paul Johnston says:

    Deary me, some people need to lighten up. Imagine fans trying to wind up others with flyers and banners alike?

    Oh and are BFC Dynamo the only Berlin club with hooligans ready to hijack a big occasion? I like this site and i like to be able to read up on the Berlin football scene but the reports on BFC always focus on the negatives!!

    • Stephen says:

      Hi Paul, thanks for your comment.

      Firstly, I’m really disappointed that you think we always focus on the negatives with Dynamo. I personally can’t tolerate the lazy labels that are attached to Dynamo by folk who have never been to the Sportforum and have never met any Dynamo fans. I therefore always try to take a very objective view of things, particularly Dynamo. Your comment means that I have to try harder to be more objective, and that’s what I will strive to do.

      My issue with the flyer (and the banner displayed before the game) was that it illustrates how Dynamo wants to have it both ways. We’re not the Stati club, but we love Mielke. We want to look to the future, but look at all the stuff we won thirty years ago. It makes sense that the club should have an identity crisis, but to revel in it so actively and then criticise others for failing to understand what Dynamo is frankly annoys me.

      The banner that said ‘L47, die Dirne vom 1.FCU’ was funny though. More winding up of other football teams, please.

  3. Paul Johnston says:

    Hi Stephen.

    Thanks for the reply, Football fans can be the most fickle people alive at times so of course they want it both ways!!

    The Clubs identity crisis in my opinion comes from lazy attitudes of people in the Press/Media and from people who believe all the negative reports about the fans…This has caused an almost siege like mentality within the fans and some people at the Club who see no change in the attitudes towards them from outsiders!

    Hence the banner and flyer at the weekend, keep bringing up the Stasi past, ok we’ll play on it and flaunt it to wind you all up!

    As for the stuff they won thirty years ago, come on Stephen are you trying to suggest they should forget it and brush it under the carpet…..They had some wonderful players and a tremendous record for top flight football in Europe, i can still recall their game against Aberdeen (my home team) in the European Cup 1984 and me being intrigued by them ever since……Holding onto their past glories does not detract from them trying to move forward as a club and gaining a promotion that could change this club forever.

    It will take work on both sides of the fence for this club to ever change public opinions, i mean in all honesty Stephen when do BFC Dynamo get air time or decent press reports even in their own City, when something negative happens!!

    You only have to look a little bit South of Dyanmo to see what can happen to a ‘Kult’ club with a little positive reporting, they weren’t always the cuddly toy of football in Berlin ;-)

  4. Paul Johnston says:

    “failing to understand what Dynamo is ”

    Please explain Stephen?

  5. Stephen says:

    “failing to understand what Dynamo is ”

    I wish I could explain! It seems that whatever those of us outside of the Dynamo family says is wrong, and that we’ll never understand the Dynamo humour or fan scene. Like you say, there certainly is a siege mentality, and you are absolutely right in saying that both sides need to change and open up.

    I personally am absolutely fascinated with Dynamo and am therefore ready to give Dynamo clean slate after clean slate, but I will criticise when I see some that I think should be criticised – just like I do with Hertha (often) and other teams (admittedly, less often).

    Thanks for the comments, Paul, enjoying the discussion! :)

  6. Paul Johnston says:

    The Dynamo fan scene is one of that akin to a dangerous animal cornered….. Very angry, on the defence and ready to bite (and bite hard)

    They’ve been kicked, slated, attacked, punished and generally bad mouthed from just about anyone and everyone around them……..More so than any other (small) club in Germany, basically because of their past Stasi links and the fans behaviour many many years ago!

    The reputation of the fans has been used against the club as long as i can remember, nowadays though there are many more fan scenes with much more problems than seen at BFC Dynamo. Yet the slightest incident or threat of an incident brings all sorts of negative reports in the local and National media and always harks back to the fan scene of old.

    Both Hertha and the Red lot from South East Berlin have had many more incidents of fan violence and disorder than BFC of late, yet…………..

    Like you Stephen i am also fascinated by BFC Dynamo, so much so i come over as often as possible to see them play and have done since my first game against Stahl Brandenburg just after the wall came down. I have made many friends amongst the fans and the staff alike and we are always made to feel very welcome, my Wife now makes the pilgramage with me and she too loves the experience even though the standard isn’t the greatest at times hahahaha. It’s hard to explain but the club has a special draw for me, from the very first game i seen them and from trying to learn more and more about them during the East German period just heightened my intrigue and i have been hooked ever since!!

    I could talk about them all day long to anyone willing to listen, perhaps one day we can discuss them over a nice Berliner Pilsner in the beautifull Berlin sun?

    P.S I have my first BFC Dynamo tattoo coming up soon ;-)

  7. paul says:

    hi stephen.ive met you a couple of times whilst in berlin(vik v bfc and litchenburg v tebe)such a shame i didnt realise you were at the bfc game on the 20th oct,i was there so i missed getting issue 3 of your fantastic mag

  8. paul says:

    Question for paul johnston.
    have you any idea where get dynamo t-shirts etc with the original logo on?i went to an address given on the site for such gear(on coppisstrasse)but its the dynamo boxing club.all help would be really appreaciated

Leave a Reply